SmallBizGenius Analysis

Dinnerly is a budget-friendly meal kit service that offers a variety of recipes and convenient delivery. While many customers praise the taste and affordability, recurring issues with missing ingredients, delivery problems, and inconsistent quality are frequently reported.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 280 recent reviews

Pricing & Value

9.0/10

Customers consistently praise Dinnerly's affordability, noting it's the lowest-priced meal kit service. Many feel it offers good value for the money, especially compared to dining out or other meal kit options. For example, reviewers say, "Dinnerly is the best value meal kit I've used" and "The prices are really economical."

40 reviews mention this

Missing Ingredients & Order Accuracy

3.0/10

A significant number of reviewers report frequently missing ingredients in their boxes, leading to frustration and incomplete meals. Some examples include missing recipe cards, produce, or even entire meals from the order. One reviewer stated, "Boxes ALWAYS have missing ingredients and/or recipe cards."

30 reviews mention this

Delivery Issues

4.0/10

Many customers experience problems with Dinnerly's delivery service, including late arrivals, missed deliveries, and damaged boxes. This unreliability disrupts meal planning and can lead to spoiled ingredients. As one reviewer noted, "I’ve had 3 deliveries, out of maybe 6 total, that are days late."

25 reviews mention this

Food Quality & Freshness

5.0/10

Some reviewers express concerns about the quality and freshness of the ingredients, citing instances of moldy produce, opened or leaking meat, and expired items. This raises concerns about food safety and overall satisfaction. For instance, a reviewer shared, "I’ve received moldy food, opened and leaking meat."

20 reviews mention this

Recipe Variety & Taste

7.0/10

Many customers appreciate the variety of recipes offered by Dinnerly and find the meals to be delicious and easy to prepare. They enjoy trying new cuisines and appreciate the convenience of having pre-portioned ingredients. One reviewer said, "The meal choices are varied, easy to prepare and delicious."

18 reviews mention this

Customer Service

4.0/10

Some reviewers report difficulty contacting customer service and resolving issues, such as missing ingredients or late deliveries. This lack of responsiveness adds to the frustration caused by other problems. A reviewer stated, "You can’t get through to customer service to talk to an actual person."

10 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Affordable meal kit option Mentioned 40x
"Dinnerly is the best value meal kit I've used."
Easy-to-prepare recipes Mentioned 18x
"The meal choices are varied, easy to prepare and delicious."
Good variety of meal choices Mentioned 18x
"Love the options, the food has all been delicious."
Convenient meal planning and delivery Mentioned 15x
"We love how it takes all the thinking out of meal prepping."
Flexibility to skip weeks Mentioned 3x
"The flexibility to skip weeks is also a plus."

Common Complaints

Frequent missing ingredients Mentioned 30x
"Boxes ALWAYS have missing ingredients and/or recipe cards."
Unreliable delivery service Mentioned 25x
"I’ve had 3 deliveries, out of maybe 6 total, that are days late."
Inconsistent food quality and freshness Mentioned 20x
"I’ve received moldy food, opened and leaking meat."
Poor customer service responsiveness Mentioned 10x
"You can’t get through to customer service to talk to an actual person."
Repetitive meal options Mentioned 5x
"After 3 weeks the meals felt like the same meals."

Common Questions About Dinnerly

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Dinnerly legit and trustworthy?

Dinnerly is a legitimate meal kit service, but its trustworthiness is questionable due to frequent reports of missing ingredients, delivery problems, and inconsistent food quality. While many customers appreciate the low prices, the recurring issues can lead to frustration and outweigh the cost savings. Customers report that the company often provides compensation for errors, but the inconvenience remains a concern. For small business owners seeking a reliable meal solution, Dinnerly may not be the most dependable option without improvements in order fulfillment and delivery.

Based on 45 reviews

Does Dinnerly have good customer service?

Dinnerly's customer service receives mixed reviews. Some customers report positive experiences when resolving issues, such as receiving credits or refunds for missing ingredients or damaged items. However, a significant number of reviewers express frustration with the difficulty of contacting customer service representatives and the lack of timely responses. Many report only being able to communicate through automated systems, making it challenging to address complex problems. Therefore, while some customers find the customer service helpful, others find it to be lacking and unresponsive.

Based on 10 reviews

Is Dinnerly worth it for small business?

Whether Dinnerly is worth it for small business owners depends on their priorities and tolerance for potential issues. If cost is the primary concern and occasional errors are acceptable, Dinnerly's low prices may be attractive. However, if reliability and consistency are crucial, the frequent reports of missing ingredients, delivery problems, and inconsistent food quality may make it a risky choice. Small business owners should weigh the cost savings against the potential for disruptions and the need for reliable meal planning.

Based on 50 reviews

What is Dinnerly's delivery service like?

Dinnerly's delivery service is a major point of contention among reviewers. While some customers receive their boxes on time and in good condition, a significant number report frequent issues, including late arrivals, missed deliveries, and damaged boxes. These problems can disrupt meal planning and lead to spoiled ingredients, causing frustration and inconvenience. The delivery inconsistencies are a recurring theme in customer feedback and a significant drawback of the service.

Based on 25 reviews